Crack Spreads, Oil Futures, and $5 Gasoline

Crack Spreads, Oil Futures, and $5 Gasoline

by | published January 7th, 2011

John Hofmeister heads up Citizens for Affordable Energy. But before he founded the group in 2008, he used to be president of Shell Oil Co., the American affiliate of Royal Dutch Shell (NYSE:RDS).

So when Hofmeister said a few days ago that gasoline could reach $5 a gallon by 2012, a lot of people sat up and took notice.

The markets responded, however, by moving in the opposite direction…

The retreat in crude oil prices over the first four trading days in 2011 actually tells us less about oil and more about the tight correlation the market has crafted between the level of the dollar and perceptions about economic recovery.

The 3.3% decline in the NYMEX futures contract this week follows an almost 9% gain in December. In explanation, pundits point to two overall factors as being primarily responsible for the move.

The first – a rising dollar – is true, but hardly sufficient to explain such a decline in trading prices.

The second tells us that concerns over market growth are depressing prices. This second rationale has always been a generic rule of thumb. But it really does not tell us anything beyond somebody’s view of a broad market direction.

Oil does trade in dollars, and (absent any other considerations) a strengthening dollar will mean fewer are needed to obtain a barrel of crude. A U.S. currency weakening against others – especially the euro – will mean it takes more greenbacks to make the same purchase, thereby increasing the price.

Yet the exchange value of the dollar is only one aspect of our approach to analyze where oil is going.

Volatility Is the New Force to Be Reckoned With

As you will recall, in addition to a range of geopolitical and short-term issues that tend to affect oil pricing, I follow five separate conventional influences: the currency exchange (or forex) consideration providing the relative strength of the dollar; constraints in availability and quality of supply; stockpile and refinery inventories; mergers and acquisitions (limiting competition); and demand – specifically industrial usage, the last holdout from the demand destruction cycle of the financial meltdown of 2008 to 2010. (See “What Crude Oil Prices Are Telling Us,” October 1, 2010).

The preferred sound bite these days to “explain” a price decline is a concern over market growth, while higher prices are often regarded as the result of a weakened currency.

Neither factor tells us very much… and they certainly do not reflect what is really happening in the trade in futures contracts – the real mover of pricing consignments of actual oil.

In addition, the market price moving forward will not simply be a result of my five “traditional” indicators. A pronounced wave of uncertainty in setting trading points will reflect the new force requiring adjustment – volatility.

Now, it is this volatility that will present the single greatest obstacle to stable pricing. Some of the instability may result from the way my five indicators relate to each other and to events. But most of it comes from the trading system itself.

Both traders and those actually producing or consuming product need to protect their investment returns or cost margins by hedging contracts. But volatility makes that more difficult.

Refineries end up at the center of these considerations. They buy the crude oil sold by the operating companies; and they then sell oil products to the retail customer.

However, there is one way to follow how the buyers and sellers of oil actually view what the market is doing. It is how both the traders in paper barrels (the future contracts) and wet barrels (the actual underlying crude or oil products) attempt to wrestle with less predictable moves up and down in the price.

It’s called a “crack spread.” This is the term for the difference in the profit margin of crude versus the profit margin of the various petroleum products that can be extracted from it – how much a refinery can expect to make from “cracking” the petroleum.

It involves playing futures contracts in crude oil against contracts in the products produced from the crude.

While any oil products can be used to determine the spread, low-sulfur-content heating oil and reformulated gasoline are the ones most often relied upon.

Crack spreads tell us what the entire gamut of buyers and sellers actually thinks about where pricing is going. That is because the usage of futures contracts in this way comprises a major way to hedge against pricing changes in the actual products bought and sold.

As of the close of trade yesterday, the near-month (February) crack spreads are telling us something very interesting…

The heating oil crack spread (heating oil versus same-duration crude oil contracts) has widened to $17.09 a barrel, the highest level in a year. Meanwhile, the February gasoline crack spread (once again, priced against crude) has risen to over $14 a barrel.

Some of this results from the impact of perceived inventory levels at refineries of both crude for processing and finished product. But the primary explanation is pointing in a very different direction…

To hedge their contracts, both buyers and sellers need to factor in higher forward prices. Further, these crack spreads are widening during the same period in which oil prices are declining.

What Crack Spreads Are Telling Us Now

The talking heads may fret about economic recovery or express the opinion that credit problems in the Eurozone will lead to a strengthening dollar. Both are certainly valid concerns, as far as they go.

But the crack spreads are telling us that traders, producers, and refineries have already made two overarching conclusions.

First, demand is moving back into the market and has been in developing sectors of the global economy for some time.

Second, there is a basic reason why oil companies have committed more money to 2011 drilling than any other single year in history: Crude oil prices are heading north. And that will result in higher retail prices for oil products, regardless of current inventories.

Hofmeister may not be correct in predicting near-term prices of $5 a gallon. But he is certainly right about the direction.



Please Note: Kent cannot respond to your comments and questions directly. But he can address them in future alerts... so keep an eye on your inbox. If you have a question about your subscription, please email us directly at

  1. Frank Hummel
    January 7th, 2011 at 13:39 | #1

    Good article. What about PVX Provident Energy and PGH Provident Engergy LTD?. Will they be ones to keep?.
    Frank Hummel

  2. Riffit Reid
    January 7th, 2011 at 16:42 | #2

    all this is a help bot what i need is some price companys that are between $2 and $5 dollars to get in on the profit and then i may be able to get in on the good stuff thanks.

    January 7th, 2011 at 19:42 | #3

    is APL still a good bet?
    Should i double down or sell?

  4. Martha Beals
    January 8th, 2011 at 10:01 | #4

    I see the price of oil going up but why is natural gas still so cheap? I keep reading that nat gas will take off once the recovery begins. Isn’t it time for nat gas to at least be valued a bit more like $6 than always hovering round $4? What is going on? Please respond.

  5. Hieny Hienrich
    January 14th, 2011 at 15:12 | #5

    @Roy Tanner
    Don’t sell your stock. Let the profits ride! We’re in for a huge jump.

  6. Hieny Hienrich
    January 14th, 2011 at 15:14 | #6

    @Martha Beals
    Martha, natural gas is so cheap because the price is down. When the price goes back up it won’t be cheap anymore. I don’t see the price going up anytime soon.

  7. pat reppin
    January 15th, 2011 at 14:37 | #7

    Like Riffit Reid, I am low on funds; hit hard in 2000-01 and again in the recent downturn. I am still holding syy, itc, & xom and a small- cap investment. I need a solid, ready to go now stock to purchase to give me a leg up on future investments. Something like $1 invested and a quick return of $5-8/per share. Any such animals living out there?

    Right now, it seems to me I am spending more on subscriptions to investment newsletters, et al, than I am investing in the market.

    Pulease —- show me the way, and quickly, pretty pulease!!!

  8. Bob Marshall
    June 10th, 2011 at 18:28 | #8

    Kent I am a retire with Total Oil Stock. Do you see oil stock going up in the future or would selling and purchasing gold make more sense? With the devavulation of the dollar gold makes perfect sense to me at this point. china is purchasing 1.1 trillion in gold from the US. Apparently they have little faith in our currency.

  9. March 20th, 2012 at 03:09 | #9

    We know that oil prices tend to fluctuate, but they always end up rising ultimately. As stories of oil reserves depleting and middle east unrest happens, oil prices are bound to surge again. Coupled with this problem is the increasing interest rates for car loans. It seems like it is getting harder for people to afford new cars.

  10. enthusceptic
    March 20th, 2012 at 10:26 | #10

    There is so much to read. Articles that are this old…

  11. Patrick
    March 24th, 2012 at 08:52 | #11

    Dr. Moors. I understand the U.S. gasoline exports have been growing. My guess is that this gasoline is being exported from the gulf region after it is refined and the crude oil source is Canadian crude. Considering all east coast refiners buy brent crude and some are shutting down due to high brent crude prices, why don’t the east coast refiners buy the Canadian crude and ship it to the east coast for refining? If this cannot be done then why can’t the gasoline refined in the gulf be shipped to the east coast versus being exported to other countries?

  1. No trackbacks yet.