Has Saudi Arabia Shot Itself in the Foot?
On Saturday, Foreign Minister Adel al-Jubeir became the latest Saudi official to downplay the kingdom’s expanding deficit. Speaking at a conference in Manama, the capital of neighboring Bahrain, the minister maintained that the current situation was manageable.
The situation, of course, has been sparked by two Saudi-led decisions within OPEC. The first was to defend global market share by keeping production high (a move made last year while Americans were sitting down to their Thanksgiving turkeys). That started a downward slide in global oil prices, accentuated by a second action.
The next move involved Riyadh opening the spigots on production, thereby further exacerbating the pricing decline. At the time, I noted here in Oil & Energy Investor that the Saudis had no choice, given what was unfolding elsewhere in OPEC.
A country like Saudi Arabia, even with its vast raw material and hard currency wealth, has its hard currency revenues exposed in trade taking place outside its borders. In a low price environment it will consistently generate reduced revenue in foreign sales while its required foreign product purchases will disproportionately increase in cost.
Why is the wealthiest OPEC nation having these problems, and how much worse can it get?
All OPEC Members Have Taken a Hit
Because the cartel members are all dependent upon oil sales and run undiversified economies, the almost 60% collapse in crude prices hit every one of them hard. Defending market share is one thing, but rendering budgets inoperable is something else altogether.
These countries may be selling 40% of the world’s oil requirements. But they also must import just about everything else they need domestically. That requires an increasing amount of hard currency since populations are rising fast (while average ages are declining to the low 20s or even beyond).
As a result, those least able to withstand the lowering revenues from crude sales simply sold more of it into the international market, further depressing prices and extenuating a downward pricing cycle.
OPEC members like Venezuela, Nigeria, Libya, Ecuador, and Iran are experiencing significant financial constriction. Each of these nations requires a crude price of well more than $120 a barrel to arrest a spreading fiscal paralysis.
But crude closed Friday in London at less than $50.
Saudi Arabia Is Losing Billions on a Weekly Basis
Having lost effective control over the pricing mechanism within OPEC, Saudi Arabia has taken a lesson from the pages of the “if you can’t beat them, join them” book club.
While Saudi Arabia, Kuwait, and the United Arab Emirates (UAE) are the most solvent OPEC producers, even they are experiencing budget deficits. Remember, they must import the bulk of their consumer products. The Saudis are rumored to be losing billions in hard currency exchange weekly.
Now, they are nowhere close to “bake sale” territory. As officials are wont to declare, they can run a deficit for decades.
But not at projected rates.
A deficit run by a rentier state (which takes profits from raw materials but provides little in the way of value-added development) tends to accelerate regardless of whether the country has the means to offset it with forex moves. A vicious cycle emerges well in advance of any threatened default or currency collapse.
Saudi Arabia Withdraws Foreign Investments
Two recent decisions made by Riyadh accentuate the kingdom’s quandary.
First, Riyadh began withdrawing investment from foreign asset funds.
Global oil sales are denominated in dollars. A producer like Saudi Arabia must stabilize what otherwise would be too much hard currency from flowing back into the domestic economy, thereby subjecting the local currency to bouts of debilitating inflation. This is accomplished by investing the money outside the country and then repatriating investment proceeds over time or using it to purchase equipment or other essential imports outside the country (capping the circulation of hard currency within the country limits the inflationary impact).
On the other hand, withdrawing outside funds means only one thing. The hard currency is required to address foreign exchange concerns.
The S&P Cuts Riyadh’s Rating
Second, Riyadh has returned to the global capital markets by issuing sovereign paper after years of staying away. The Saudis used to tout the strength of their economy by refusing to draw from debt markets. Not anymore.
Another indication that even the normally revenue-heavy OPEC leader has to watch its exchange balance. This has hardly gone unnoticed in the market.
Standard & Poor’s cut the Saudi credit rating from “AA-” “A+” last week, saying in addition that it was retaining a negative outlook. As expected, the Saudi Finance Ministry was quick to issue a strongly worded reaction, maintaining that the S&P move was “reactionary,” driven by “fluid market conditions rather than economic fundamentals.”
Nobody in the business really buys that view. The Saudi “economic” perspective has little going for it other than the global selling of oil. Little else is produced there, and the service industry is largely provided by foreign nationals.
The Saudi Problem Is Long Term
Until a higher (and more resilient) pricing floor can be commanded for crude, the Saudi situation will not be improving.
Now, the environment is hardly better in non-OPEC major produces like Russia, where many of the same problems earlier on pummeled the ruble. In the U.S., where increasing shale and tight oil volume has profoundly changed assumptions about worldwide available reserves, the situation is different. The American market is populated by private producers, not state-controlled companies. There, a market really can develop and regulate the trade.
The Saudis are certainly not a basket case, and their access to oil sale revenues will continue unabated. But the attempt to diversify the economy is still languishing, and that will become more problematic the longer low oil prices remain.
Crude below $50 a barrel is a short-term consideration. The more fundamental Saudi economic problem is not. I’ll be monitoring the situation and keeping you informed as this situation plays out.