The Two Trends Shaking the Oil Industry Today

The Two Trends Shaking the Oil Industry Today

by | published November 10th, 2015

Accelerating changes in the oil sector are leading to two major emerging trends.

This morning, the International Energy Agency (IEA) in Paris reported that global investment cuts in forward capital commitments for new projects continue to intensify, with the current total in excess of $20 billion. Extrapolations made by other analysts quickly put another zero on the amount if extended out a few years.

With crude languishing at $45 a barrel in New York and less than $50 in London, this is the latest signal that the low prices for oil are initiating a pullback in projects. But it is the range of the cuts this time around that is interesting.

And this development is spurring a second, more extreme effect on the sector…

The U.S. and Canada Delay New Drilling Projects

We have already witnessed postponements in more expensive unconventional drilling in the U.S. and corresponding delays in Canada on new oil sands projects.

These were the first expenditures to come under pressure. Deeper, horizontal, fracked drilling is much more expensive than conventional, shallower, vertical production. With the average shale project requiring outlays of $5 million or more per well, average prices would need to be in excess of $70 a barrel to break even.

Shale and tight wells provide most of their volume upfront, usually in the first 18 months. And while production could continue at a lower rate for much longer, the problem of realizing a sufficient return on investment (ROI) persists. With the bulk of the oil coming up when prices are low, ROI declines significantly… and the attractiveness of the project along with it.

As New Shale Sources Enter the Picture, Saudis Will Fight for Market Share

The American shale and tight oil sector had been one of two main targets for the OPEC decision last Thanksgiving to maintain production (the other being the Saudi concern over Russian inroads into the Asian market). Increasing production from the new sources was projecting major shifts in market share. OPEC needed to curtail that.

And for good reason. The current contest with U.S. unconventional sourcing is hardly going to resolve the matter. American companies are first out of the gate, but the vast majority (almost 77%) of recoverable shale/tight oil worldwide is located someplace else.

That means the Saudis are going to be fighting this market share battle repeatedly as new competing sources are phased in. Regulatory, property ownership, infrastructure, and a number of other impediments may slow the process. But it is coming, and Riyadh knows it.

Overall Demand Levels Are Going to Rise

The IEA also cautions that a new round of geopolitical imbalances may result. It is important to remember that the demand levels worldwide are not declining. In fact, we are seeing once again the development of a rise. Some of this is because cheaper prices usually occasion greater consumption. But this is also because the overall demand base is moving up.

Yet none of this is going to rescue the more expensive part of the forward capital expenditure curve in time to keep the second shoe from falling.

That’s the second trend coming into focus.

Bigger Companies Are Now Entering the M&A Cycle

On several occasions here in Oil & Energy Investor I have commented on an inevitable merger and acquisition (M&A) cycle resulting from the prolonged low crude prices. We have already witnessed a number of small companies go belly up, with that activity intensifying beyond the upstream sector (field production companies) into midstream pipeline, transport, gathering, initial processing, and storage facilities.

Augmenting this action has been a rise in companies surviving bankruptcy by selling off selected field, lease, and other hard assets. While many of these have been private holdings, others are publicly traded.

However, a new wrinkle has surfaced here as well. Yesterday, oil and natural gas producer Apache Corp. (NYSE:APA) acknowledged it had received an unsolicited takeover bid from an unnamed entity. That resulted in a 19.2% rise in its share price in less than one and a half trading sessions (through late morning today). Apache has clearly emphasized that the offer has been rejected and that the company has no plans to sell.

That resulted in the price cooling off. On the other hand, it leaves us with this: The M&A interest is now extending into larger targets (whether those targets are interested in selling or not). As of close yesterday, APA had a market cap of just under $20 billion, much bigger than any of the companies on the radar previously.

This about to get even more interesting.

Please Note: Kent cannot respond to your comments and questions directly. But he can address them in future alerts... so keep an eye on your inbox. If you have a question about your subscription, please email us directly at

  1. Ed M
    November 10th, 2015 at 21:33 | #1

    I would like to ask about the length of time oil is expected to be at such a low price. It would seem that rig count in the US has to drop perhaps another 50 % or more based on historical precedent. Shale is hard and expensive to get out of the ground. All this being said the overriding issue is that the Saudis are still the boss in that their actions have created the low price environment. As I said in commenting on another article here it is hard to see how it can be said that the Saudis are in a compromised position and that they are no longer in charge. So how can the US assert itself ?

  2. Jonathan
    November 12th, 2015 at 06:07 | #2

    sir, there is lot of action in Oil/gas space in north america. i wish i could work as a truck driver and earn that $100k annual salary! because my computing skills and stock tradin skills are useless

  3. Mark Richards
    November 15th, 2015 at 13:47 | #3

    The statement below in your article raises a question?

    “The IEA also cautions that a new round of geopolitical imbalances may result. It is important to remember that the demand levels worldwide are not declining. In fact, we are seeing once again the development of a rise. Some of this is because cheaper prices usually occasion greater consumption. But this is also because the overall demand base is moving up.”

    With this being said concerning “suppy and demand” what will happen in your opinion once the US realizes there is a shortage in O&G? Will this drive Oil prices to an unpredictable price?

    Thanks for your insite!

  4. November 23rd, 2015 at 16:09 | #4

    Oil industry experts well know that KSA excess in production to protect its market is a fallacy. The truth did not wait long to arise. Barrel price at $40 is still very profitable to shale oil producers; whose market is mainly USA. KSA main market is the far East and Europe. Obviously the oil at 40 or 50 is forcing the oil companies to delay projects, specially those in the lower ROI scale. KSA market is 8.5 MMbpd fixed by OPEC, while its production is more than 10.5 MMbpd; simply the Saudis are stealing 2 MM of others’ market, which in fact is over supplied. KSA will be forced by the events to reduce its production aimimg to get more $ with higher price. Saudi money reserves reduced in more than $200B in the last 12 months. The war in Yemen is costly to KSA and is prolonging more than expected.

  1. No trackbacks yet.